Connect with us

World

Covid contract case sheds light on the government’s relationship with the truth | UK News

Published

on

Covid contract case sheds light on the government’s relationship with the truth |  UK News

The chronicle will be the main accusation against the government after the Supreme Court ruling that the Cabinet Office acted illegally, with “apparent partiality”, when it awarded a contract last March to a company run by long-term partners of Michael. Gove and Dominic Cummings. .

But the Good Law Project’s victory, and the Cabinet tumult during the pandemic it exposed, has raised another fundamental question about integrity: the government’s relationship to the truth.

The careful judgment of Mrs. Justice O’Farrell, rejecting a fierce defense by the government, was that it had been illegal to even consider for work (conducting focus groups on Covid-19 health messages) any company other than the one whose owners and work Cummings knew, rated and trusted.

But the government’s response to what could have been a humiliating defeat was to say, for the communication of the media to the public, that: “The ruling makes it clear that there was no indication of real bias in the decision to award the contract, it was not due to personal or professional connections. “

There are two parts along that line, the first of which is quicker to explain: the judge did say that there was no “suggestion of actual bias”, because the Good Law Project (GLP) did not make that claim. His challenge to judicial review was a claim of “apparent bias”, which has its own legal formulation.

The second part is more complicated. The government was telling the public that, according to the judge, its decision to award the contract to Public First “was not due to any personal or professional connection.”

Legal trials exist to be scrutinized, but even so, without contortions, it is difficult to see this government line, in its official response, as anything other than misleading to the public.

It resolves the original denial from the Cabinet Office when The Guardian and openDemocracy first reported on the contract last summer. They said it was “silly” to suggest, as it seemed, that long-standing ties between Cummings and Gove, and Public First owners James Frayne and Rachel Wolf, who had previously worked with them, were a factor in the award of this contract.

Cummings himself appeared to overturn that position with his own witness statement in February. He acknowledged that Wolf and Frayne are his friends, although he said he had not met Frayne since 2016. Cummings told the court that his knowledge of his approach and the work of his company was key to his opinion that the government needed to hire Public. First to perform the test. the effectiveness of his messages on Covid-19, and urged public officials to commission them.

“The fact that I knew the key people at Public First well was a benefit, not a problem,” Cummings said.

In its own detailed defense, the government presented these personal relationships as a virtue, stating: “The past professional connection simply allowed a better judgment to be reached as to whether Public First was really the best / only appropriate body to perform services as it was. necessary”.

O’Farrell really accepted it; people who have been around for a long time will get to know each other. Its defining point, however, is that the government, which spends public money, even in a pandemic, had to have some process and criteria, to at least consider other companies, to ensure that there was no “apparent bias” in the designation of the person with whom there were personal connections.

In the face of that defeat, the government could have apologized for that failure, and legal costs of around £ 600,000, plus probably having to pay LPG costs as well. Instead, they issued a public statement that the contract was not delivered to Public First “due to personal or professional connections,” apparently at odds with their own case and the facts set forth by GLP’s determination.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement

Lifestyle

The 7 best epic novels you will want to read and reread over and over again The 7 best epic novels you will want to read and reread over and over again
LifeStyle12 hours ago

The 7 best epic novels you will want to read and reread over and over again

Despite concerns about the early pandemic that eventually run out of good TVHonestly, I don’t feel like we’ve ever done...

6 small patio design ideas to make the most of your space 6 small patio design ideas to make the most of your space
LifeStyle12 hours ago

6 small patio design ideas to make the most of your space

I think we can all agree that this summer More than ever We are excited to do each and every...

Food delivery companies are popping up in S’pore, but complaints are on the rise Food delivery companies are popping up in S’pore, but complaints are on the rise
LifeStyle13 hours ago

Food delivery companies are popping up in S’pore, but complaints are on the rise

It seems that negative comments about food delivery companies abound online. A quick glance at the Facebook pages of the...

How are delivery-only food and beverage brands affected in cloud kitchens during MCO? How are delivery-only food and beverage brands affected in cloud kitchens during MCO?
LifeStyle13 hours ago

How are delivery-only food and beverage brands affected in cloud kitchens during MCO?

With dinners banned during closures, many restaurants have had to switch online and offer their wares through delivery and takeout....

Malaysian indie game developer behind The Company Man Malaysian indie game developer behind The Company Man
LifeStyle14 hours ago

Malaysian indie game developer behind The Company Man

At a time when many of us are WFH and lacking office culture (or not, there is no judgment here),...

Coworking and coliving hotel in Gua Musang, Kelantan Coworking and coliving hotel in Gua Musang, Kelantan
LifeStyle17 hours ago

Coworking and coliving hotel in Gua Musang, Kelantan

Only recently have we noticed new coworking space launches in Klang Valley slowing down. Considering the pandemic and travel restrictions,...

4 Nutritionist Approved Healthy Foods on Amazon to Update Your Pantry 4 Nutritionist Approved Healthy Foods on Amazon to Update Your Pantry
LifeStyle1 day ago

4 Nutritionist Approved Healthy Foods on Amazon to Update Your Pantry

In a dream world, healthy, nutrient-dense meals would be easily accessible to everyone. Buying quinoa, leafy greens, and other superfoods...

Where the magic of Tata Harper happens Where the magic of Tata Harper happens
LifeStyle1 day ago

Where the magic of Tata Harper happens

Tata Harper is famous for doing most of the manufacturing of her clean, natural skincare on her farm in Vermont,...

The Best Summer Pasta Salad Recipe You Must Try This Season The Best Summer Pasta Salad Recipe You Must Try This Season
LifeStyle1 day ago

The Best Summer Pasta Salad Recipe You Must Try This Season

I am currently sitting in my parents’ backyard, an oasis in the heart of Northern California, it is my happy...

Top 9 Dating Apps For 30s – Time To Find The Real Deal! Top 9 Dating Apps For 30s – Time To Find The Real Deal!
LifeStyle1 day ago

Top 9 Dating Apps For 30s – Time To Find The Real Deal!

Even if you’re the type of person who loves the thrill of the hunt, the seemingly endless dating carousel can...

Advertisement

Sport

PH Olympians Get Status, Monthly Pay Update PH Olympians Get Status, Monthly Pay Update
Sports1 min ago

PH Olympians Get Status, Monthly Pay Update

Filipino athletes who qualified for the Tokyo Olympics will automatically get an increase in their status and monthly salary, the...

Kerr: Durant ‘more talented’ than Jordan Kerr: Durant ‘more talented’ than Jordan
Sports8 mins ago

Kerr: Durant ‘more talented’ than Jordan

Steve Kerr won three NBA championships as Michael Jordan’s teammate in Chicago and another two as Kevin Durant’s coach at...

Ronaldo scores two against France to reach 109 goals, Portugal advances Ronaldo scores two against France to reach 109 goals, Portugal advances
Sports23 mins ago

Ronaldo scores two against France to reach 109 goals, Portugal advances

BUDAPEST, Hungary – Cristiano Ronaldo scored two penalties to tie the men’s overall goal record with 109 goals and Portugal...

Dodgers activate Cody Bellinger after 12-day stint in IL Dodgers activate Cody Bellinger after 12-day stint in IL
Sports30 mins ago

Dodgers activate Cody Bellinger after 12-day stint in IL

The Dodgers announced they have reinstated the outfielder Cody Bellinger before tonight’s game against the Padres. Infielder Andy burns has...

Knott and Watanabe join other PH bets at the Tokyo Games Knott and Watanabe join other PH bets at the Tokyo Games
Sports44 mins ago

Knott and Watanabe join other PH bets at the Tokyo Games

Kristina Marie Knott. RESEARCH FILE PHOTO MANILA, Philippines – Kristina Knott and judoka Kiyomi Watanabe received their spots for the...

Davante Adams hints again that he could leave the Packers after the season Davante Adams hints again that he could leave the Packers after the season
Sports52 mins ago

Davante Adams hints again that he could leave the Packers after the season

Four-time Green Bay Packers wide receiver Davante Adams is in the final year of his contract and assured everyone earlier...

Canadians emerge as price favorites in NHL playoff series Canadians emerge as price favorites in NHL playoff series
Sports1 hour ago

Canadians emerge as price favorites in NHL playoff series

The Montreal Canadiens can score their ticket to the Stanley Cup final for the first time in 28 years with...

Who is Ime Udoka?  Four things to know about the Celtics’ next head coach Who is Ime Udoka?  Four things to know about the Celtics’ next head coach
Sports1 hour ago

Who is Ime Udoka? Four things to know about the Celtics’ next head coach

The Celtics seem to have found their next head coach. ESPN’s Adrian Wojnarowski reported Wednesday that Boston is closing a...

Stroman ‘optimistic’ about his next outing after injury scare Stroman ‘optimistic’ about his next outing after injury scare
Sports1 hour ago

Stroman ‘optimistic’ about his next outing after injury scare

New York Mets starting right-hander Marcus Stroman gave the club its latest injury scare when he exited Tuesday’s home game...

What would an appearance in the Stanley Cup final mean for the city of Montreal? What would an appearance in the Stanley Cup final mean for the city of Montreal?
Sports1 hour ago

What would an appearance in the Stanley Cup final mean for the city of Montreal?

var adServerUrl = “”; var $ el = $ (“# video_container-789349”); var permalink = $ el.closest (‘. snet-single-article’). data (‘permalink’);...

Advertisement

Entertainment

Britney Spears breaks the silence talking about the Conservatory: quotes about rumors Britney Spears breaks the silence talking about the Conservatory: quotes about rumors
Entertainment18 seconds ago

Britney Spears breaks the silence talking about the Conservatory: quotes about rumors

Britney Spears broke her silence about her guardianship in an impassioned speech delivered via Zoom during her trial on Wednesday...

John Boyega denies report that he walked away from Netflix movie John Boyega denies report that he walked away from Netflix movie
Entertainment2 mins ago

John Boyega denies report that he walked away from Netflix movie

Earlier this month it was reported that John Boyega had retired from Netflix. Rebel Ridge film midway through shooting. According...

Scarlett Johansson’s ‘Black Widow’ projected to debut with $ 90 million Scarlett Johansson’s ‘Black Widow’ projected to debut with $ 90 million
Entertainment3 mins ago

Scarlett Johansson’s ‘Black Widow’ projected to debut with $ 90 million

The Marvel movie also wants to hit Disney Plus in July. Long-term box office screenings see Scarlett Johansson Black widow...

‘F9’ is a blast, until the melodrama drags him back to earth ‘F9’ is a blast, until the melodrama drags him back to earth
Entertainment11 mins ago

‘F9’ is a blast, until the melodrama drags him back to earth

There is a short scene in F9—The last installment of the Fast and Furious cycle of films, which will premiere...

According to Taraji P. Henson, the separation from Empire has been suspended. According to Taraji P. Henson, the separation from Empire has been suspended.
Entertainment22 mins ago

According to Taraji P. Henson, the separation from Empire has been suspended.

June 23, 2021 Imperia has been suspended. Taraji P. Henson The hit drama is set to be transformed into a...

Entertainment One Hires Fox’s Gabriel Marano as Executive Vice President of Scripted Television – News Block Entertainment One Hires Fox’s Gabriel Marano as Executive Vice President of Scripted Television – News Block
Entertainment25 mins ago

Entertainment One Hires Fox’s Gabriel Marano as Executive Vice President of Scripted Television – News Block

Entertainment One said Wednesday that it hired Fox executive Gabriel Marano as executive vice president of Scripted Television. You will...

Why Prince Harry’s Trip To The UK For The Diana Monument Will Be Quick Why Prince Harry’s Trip To The UK For The Diana Monument Will Be Quick
Entertainment33 mins ago

Why Prince Harry’s Trip To The UK For The Diana Monument Will Be Quick

Fast travel! Prince harryTime in the UK will be short as he and his brother Prince william They will gather...

Drake Bell may face verdict on charges of danger to children Drake Bell may face verdict on charges of danger to children
Entertainment43 mins ago

Drake Bell may face verdict on charges of danger to children

news Drake Bell may face verdict on charges of danger to children Drake Bell pleaded guilty to attempting to endanger...

Scarlett Johansson to produce and star in Tower of Terror film for Disney Scarlett Johansson to produce and star in Tower of Terror film for Disney
Entertainment45 mins ago

Scarlett Johansson to produce and star in Tower of Terror film for Disney

Not all Disney theme park attractions can be successfully adapted to the big screen. For each pirates of the Caribbean,...

TikToker confirms Disney Park hack to get free t-shirt TikToker confirms Disney Park hack to get free t-shirt
Entertainment46 mins ago

TikToker confirms Disney Park hack to get free t-shirt

Disney merchandising, as everyone knows, is expensive. But a TikToker appears to have been proven to be a gimmick that...

Advertisement

Tech

House Judiciary Committee Discusses Antitrust Legislation to Curb Big Tech House Judiciary Committee Discusses Antitrust Legislation to Curb Big Tech
Tech6 mins ago

House Judiciary Committee Discusses Antitrust Legislation to Curb Big Tech

The House Judiciary Committee began debating five antitrust bills designed to curb the influence of Big Tech giants on Wednesday....

The best games for Sonic fans |  Me more The best games for Sonic fans |  Me more
Tech10 mins ago

The best games for Sonic fans | Me more

Source: Sonic World This year is the 30th anniversary of a gaming classic, Sonic the Hedgehog. One of the best...

Apple has released a slightly revised AirTag firmware Apple has released a slightly revised AirTag firmware
Tech21 mins ago

Apple has released a slightly revised AirTag firmware

AirTag’s anti-stalking features were updated in 1.0.276, and Apple has released a new version of that update for users. Unlike...

Why I decided to ditch my iPhone case and let my phone strip Why I decided to ditch my iPhone case and let my phone strip
Tech28 mins ago

Why I decided to ditch my iPhone case and let my phone strip

There are a lot of really nice iPhone cases out there. But the iPhone is also really pretty on its...

Watch this mockumentary ‘investigation’ into the origins of PUBG’s deathmatches Watch this mockumentary ‘investigation’ into the origins of PUBG’s deathmatches
Tech32 mins ago

Watch this mockumentary ‘investigation’ into the origins of PUBG’s deathmatches

In context: Each game we play resides in a universe of its own, and each one has a unique tradition...

French court will hear the complaint from the App Store in September French court will hear the complaint from the App Store in September
Tech42 mins ago

French court will hear the complaint from the App Store in September

A French court has set a date to hear a case brought against Apple by the country’s Finance Ministry for...

Microsoft prepares Windows 11 for a post-pandemic world Microsoft prepares Windows 11 for a post-pandemic world
Tech49 mins ago

Microsoft prepares Windows 11 for a post-pandemic world

Microsoft’s top software is about to be revised. Angela Lang / CNET The coronavirus has irrevocably changed the way we...

Antivirus creator John McAfee found dead in prison cell Antivirus creator John McAfee found dead in prison cell
Tech54 mins ago

Antivirus creator John McAfee found dead in prison cell

Former antivirus software creator John McAfee died in what was reported to be a suicide while awaiting extradition to face...

House judiciary passes bill to increase antitrust enforcement budget House judiciary passes bill to increase antitrust enforcement budget
Tech1 hour ago

House judiciary passes bill to increase antitrust enforcement budget

The Judiciary Committee of the US House of Representatives voted to pass a bill to increase the budgets of antitrust...

John McAfee, software pioneer turned fugitive, dies in Spanish prison John McAfee, software pioneer turned fugitive, dies in Spanish prison
Tech1 hour ago

John McAfee, software pioneer turned fugitive, dies in Spanish prison

John David McAfee, the founder of the antivirus software maker that bears his name, died in a prison in Spain...

Advertisement
Advertisement