Tuesday, September 27, 2022
Home POLITICS Supreme Court dissent on abortion case

Supreme Court dissent on abortion case

A conservative majority on the Supreme Court overturned roe v. calf on Friday, overturning decades of precedent protecting abortion rights in the United States.

in a scorching dissentthe court’s three liberal justices, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan, denounced what they said was an “arrogant approach to nullifying” women’s rights.

“One result of today’s decision is certain: the reduction of women’s rights and their status as free and equal citizens,” the justices wrote.

The trio noted that the majority opinion would open the way for states to impose bans up to the point of fertilization, as well as bans on emergency contraception.

“They have passed laws with no exceptions for when women are victims of rape or incest,” the liberals wrote. “Under those laws, a woman will have to give birth to her rapist’s son or a little girl to her father, regardless of whether doing so will destroy her life.”

They noted that states could jail women even for trying to have an abortion or make it illegal to travel out of state to get one.

They said Friday’s ruling will weigh most heavily on poorer women who can’t afford to travel between states or abroad for abortions.

“The Constitution, today’s majority contends, will not provide protection, despite its guarantees of freedom and equality for all,” the trio wrote.

They also warned that, despite majority claims to the contrary, other rights could potentially be reconsidered by the Supreme Court, including same-sex relationships, marriage for same-sex couples, and the right to contraception. In his concurring majority opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the court should reconsider these cases.

Crucially, the liberal justices argued, the majority had displayed an “arrogant approach” to overturning decades of established precedent, or so-called stare decisis.

“Most have no good reason for the upheaval in law and society that it triggers,” they wrote.

“The Court is changing course today for one reason and one reason only: because the composition of this Court has changed.”

Here is the dissenting opinion of the liberal justices In its whole:


Hill employees form the first union in Congress

The wave of union organizing that hit Amazon, Starbucks and Trader Joe's reached a new workplace this week: the United States Congress.Staff members in...

This group of activists took advantage of the partisan politics of COVID to create a big problem for Anthony Fauci and the NIH

washington post reported later that Fauci's office received 3,600 calls in 36 hours, causing his assistant to stop answering the...


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisment -

Most Popular

Tim Cook: “There is no good excuse” for the lack of women in technology

Apple CEO tells BBC that the tech sector needs more women to thrive.

Shot reveals new PS5 model moving to new 6nm ‘Oberon Plus’ chip

In one word: Since the launch of the PlayStation 5, Sony has tried to mitigate its supply problems with slight revisions...

NASA successfully crashes a spacecraft into an asteroid

NASA has successfully crashed a spacecraft into an asteroid in the first planetary defense mission aimed at changing the direction of a celestial body. Exactly...

My Alaskan Native Community Needs The Willow Oil Project

Utqiagvik, AlaskaThe long-delayed Willow oil field project, which is located within the National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska (NPR-A), is vital to Alaska's economy, to America's energy...