Connect with us

World

Virginia Supreme Court to Hear Cases Contesting Removal of Confederate Statue | Virginia

Published

on

Virginia Supreme Court to Hear Cases Contesting Removal of Confederate Statue |  Virginia

Virginia’s Supreme Court will hear arguments this week in legal challenges to Governor Ralph Northam’s plan to tear down a 131-year-old statue of Confederate General Robert E Lee, a move that received widespread praise from activists who had long viewed it as a symbol of white supremacy.

A year after Northam’s announcement, the massive bronze equestrian statue still towers over a roundabout on Monument Avenue in downtown Richmond, held in place by two lawsuits.

Among the central questions for the court to decide, is the Commonwealth of Virginia bound by a decision made by state officials more than 130 years ago, or can it undo that decision because the public’s attitude toward Confederate symbols has changed?

The plaintiffs’ attorneys will argue that the governor does not have the authority to remove the statue, while Attorney General Mark Herring will ask the court to uphold the rulings of a lower court.

Northam’s decision to tear down the statue was announced 10 days after George Floyd was killed under the knees of a Minneapolis police officer, during nightly protests of police brutality and racism across the country, including Richmond.

Residents who own property near the statue and a descendant of the signers of an 1890 deed filed separate lawsuits that transferred the statue, the pedestal, and the land on which they sit to the state.

In the latest lawsuit, William Gregory argues that the state agreed to “faithfully protect” and “affectionately protect” the statue.

In the other lawsuit, five owners, including lead plaintiff Helen Marie Taylor, say that a joint 1889 resolution of the Virginia general assembly accepting the statue and agreeing to keep it is binding. They say Northam’s order to remove the statue exceeded the governor’s authority.

During a trial in October, the state argued that it cannot be forced to maintain a statue that no longer reflects its values. Richmond Circuit Court Judge W Reilly Marchant agreed, finding that enforcing the 19th century writing would violate “current public policy.”

The judge cited two budget bills passed by the general assembly last year that repealed the 1889 law that authorized the then-governor to accept the gift of the monument and ordered the Department of General Services to remove the 13-ton sculpture. The plaintiffs argue that the budget bills were unconstitutional.

“What residents are saying is that the state cannot arbitrarily take away their property rights or remove a historic landmark, in violation of the Virginia Constitution. If the governor finds this statement astonishing, it can only be because he has an unlimited vision of governmental power. The state must comply with its contractual obligations, just like private citizens, ”argues attorney Patrick McSweeney in a legal brief filed with the Supreme Court.

The city of Richmond, which was the capital of the Confederacy for most of the civil war, has removed more than a dozen other Confederate statues since Floyd’s death, prompting the removal of monuments across the country.

Herring argues that leaving the massive Lee memorial in its place will continue to cause pain for many who see it as a symbol of oppression.

“This monument to Virginia’s racist history has held a place of honor in Richmond for far too long. Lee’s statue does not represent the ideals that Virginians live by today and the inclusive community we strive to be and it is time to tear it down, ”Herring said.

Gregory’s attorney, Joseph Blackburn, argues that removing the statue would cause irreparable damage.

“For 130 years, his family has taken pride in the Lee Monument and his family’s role in locating the Monument on land that originally belonged to his family and was given to the Commonwealth in consideration of the Commonwealth’s guarantee that I would perpetually care for and protect the Monument, ”Blackburn wrote in a letter.

It is unclear how long the Supreme Court will take to issue its decision. The court generally has an average of six to nine weeks to render judgments after oral arguments, but there are wide variations between cases.

The statue is now covered in graffiti.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement
Advertisement

Lifestyle

32 cute summer date ideas for every type of couple 32 cute summer date ideas for every type of couple
LifeStyle12 hours ago

32 cute summer date ideas for every type of couple

A big date is always in style, but there is something about the summer that makes planning a meeting even...

15 naturally sweetened desserts for when you’re cutting back on sugar 15 naturally sweetened desserts for when you’re cutting back on sugar
LifeStyle1 day ago

15 naturally sweetened desserts for when you’re cutting back on sugar

About a year ago, I realized (or just came out of denial …) that I needed to do something about...

What are carbohydrates?  Are they really the enemy?  Let’s find out What are carbohydrates?  Are they really the enemy?  Let’s find out
LifeStyle1 day ago

What are carbohydrates? Are they really the enemy? Let’s find out

Editor’s note: McKel Hill, MS, RDN, LDN is a dietitian and founder of Nutrition stripped away. Over the years, I...

Pea salad with mint and microgreens Pea salad with mint and microgreens
LifeStyle1 day ago

Pea salad with mint and microgreens

** This recipe is from our Tastemakers interview with Kennesha Buycks. Read the full story here! ** The Pea Salad...

Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt
LifeStyle1 day ago

Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt

** This recipe is from our Tastemakers interview with Kennesha Buycks. Read the full story here! ** The post Roasted...

Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt
LifeStyle1 day ago

Roasted Mushrooms with Thyme and Smoked Salt

** This recipe is from our Tastemakers interview with Kennesha Buycks. Read the full story here! ** The post Roasted...

15 quick and healthy dinner recipes to get you through the week 15 quick and healthy dinner recipes to get you through the week
LifeStyle1 day ago

15 quick and healthy dinner recipes to get you through the week

Even the most avid home cooks can occasionally go blank – sometimes, you fall into a race and just can’t...

Instagram store M’sian selling homemade tahini cookies Instagram store M’sian selling homemade tahini cookies
LifeStyle2 days ago

Instagram store M’sian selling homemade tahini cookies

With many IG companies popping up these days, fresh, locally made cookies from various recipes are one of the things...

Dinner will resume on June 21, but with a limit of just two people Dinner will resume on June 21, but with a limit of just two people
LifeStyle2 days ago

Dinner will resume on June 21, but with a limit of just two people

The Ministry of Health (MOH) announced last Thursday (June 10) that Singapore is moving into Phase 3 (Heightened Alert). While...

Moving on to pizza deliveries during MCO Moving on to pizza deliveries during MCO
LifeStyle2 days ago

Moving on to pizza deliveries during MCO

Crackhouse Comedy Club (Crackhouse) has been home to local comedians, including Dr. Jason Leong, Joanne Kam, Hannah Azlan, and Kavin...

Advertisement

Sport

Showering from Canadiens Will Isolate For 14 Days After Positive COVID Test Showering from Canadiens Will Isolate For 14 Days After Positive COVID Test
Sports10 mins ago

Showering from Canadiens Will Isolate For 14 Days After Positive COVID Test

Montreal Canadiens Head coach Dominique Ducharme will have to be quarantined for 14 days before rejoining the team after testing...

Yankees’ Gio Urshela recovers from bat splinter to eye and home run ahead in win Yankees’ Gio Urshela recovers from bat splinter to eye and home run ahead in win
Sports16 mins ago

Yankees’ Gio Urshela recovers from bat splinter to eye and home run ahead in win

Gio Urshela found out the hard way Saturday how dangerous broken bats can be. He was batting in the second...

Will MLB umpires begin checking pitchers for foreign substances on Monday? Will MLB umpires begin checking pitchers for foreign substances on Monday?
Sports17 mins ago

Will MLB umpires begin checking pitchers for foreign substances on Monday?

Major League Baseball umpires will reportedly begin checking pitchers for foreign substances on Monday, according to ESPN’s Jesse Rogers. Pitchers...

Baldwin highlights ‘lucky shot’ comment to build motivation as Gilas fights Korea again Baldwin highlights ‘lucky shot’ comment to build motivation as Gilas fights Korea again
Sports31 mins ago

Baldwin highlights ‘lucky shot’ comment to build motivation as Gilas fights Korea again

Justine Baltazar had 11 points and nine rebounds to lead Gilas PH’s charge against Indonesia. —PHOTO COURTESY OF FIBA After...

Kawhi reportedly not going to Phoenix, rehabbing at home Kawhi reportedly not going to Phoenix, rehabbing at home
Sports38 mins ago

Kawhi reportedly not going to Phoenix, rehabbing at home

It appears the Los Angeles Clippers will be without Kawhi Leonard for at least the first two games of the...

Report: Leonard will continue to rehab at home, will not travel with Clippers Report: Leonard will continue to rehab at home, will not travel with Clippers
Sports53 mins ago

Report: Leonard will continue to rehab at home, will not travel with Clippers

Los Angeles Clippers star Kawhi Leonard will reportedly not travel with the team to Phoenix and will instead continue to...

Blackhawks would be interested in Jack Eichel Blackhawks would be interested in Jack Eichel
Sports1 hour ago

Blackhawks would be interested in Jack Eichel

There are already enough teams interested in Acorn jack, and it looks like Chicago can be added to the mix....

Young PH archers aim for Tokyo tickets Young PH archers aim for Tokyo tickets
Sports1 hour ago

Young PH archers aim for Tokyo tickets

With little expectation, a young band of Filipino archers set out in search of Olympic spots starting Saturday at their...

Magic day for Hungary, disappointment for France in memorable euro draw Magic day for Hungary, disappointment for France in memorable euro draw
Sports1 hour ago

Magic day for Hungary, disappointment for France in memorable euro draw

Attila Fiola will feature prominently on all the featured reels that have been produced about Euro 2021. The Hungarian side’s...

Sergio García’s shot bounces off the flagpole at the US Open Sergio García’s shot bounces off the flagpole at the US Open
Sports1 hour ago

Sergio García’s shot bounces off the flagpole at the US Open

It’s clearly not Sergio Garcia’s day at the US Open. Garcia hit perhaps the most unfortunate shot of the entire...

Advertisement

Entertainment

Naya Rivera’s Son Josey Graduates From Pre-K as Ryan Dorsey Celebrates: ‘Proud Daddy’ Naya Rivera’s Son Josey Graduates From Pre-K as Ryan Dorsey Celebrates: ‘Proud Daddy’
Entertainment12 mins ago

Naya Rivera’s Son Josey Graduates From Pre-K as Ryan Dorsey Celebrates: ‘Proud Daddy’

Naya Rivera’s Son Josey Graduates From Pre-K as Ryan Dorsey Celebrates: ‘Proud Daddy’

Paul Walker’s daughter’s meadow looks stunning at ‘F9’ premiere Paul Walker’s daughter’s meadow looks stunning at ‘F9’ premiere
Entertainment21 mins ago

Paul Walker’s daughter’s meadow looks stunning at ‘F9’ premiere

“You don’t turn your back on the family.” The late Paul walkerdaughter of Meadow, paid tribute by walking the red...

Lawyer Claims He ‘Verified’ Erika Jayne Stole Money From Thomas Girardi, Alleges RHOBH Star Received Over $ 20 Million Lawyer Claims He ‘Verified’ Erika Jayne Stole Money From Thomas Girardi, Alleges RHOBH Star Received Over $ 20 Million
Entertainment27 mins ago

Lawyer Claims He ‘Verified’ Erika Jayne Stole Money From Thomas Girardi, Alleges RHOBH Star Received Over $ 20 Million

Credit: Milla Cochran / startraksphoto.com, SURQ / BACKGRID The attorney hired to investigate Erika jayneAssets explain why your investigation needs...

KUWTK: Kim Kardashian talks about the Van Jones and Maluma romance rumors after Soulja Boy fired his shot too! KUWTK: Kim Kardashian talks about the Van Jones and Maluma romance rumors after Soulja Boy fired his shot too!
Entertainment33 mins ago

KUWTK: Kim Kardashian talks about the Van Jones and Maluma romance rumors after Soulja Boy fired his shot too!

In the midst of her divorce from Kanye West, Kim Kardashian has linked up with a number of different men,...

Queen Elizabeth II attends Royal Ascot 2021: photo Queen Elizabeth II attends Royal Ascot 2021: photo
Entertainment42 mins ago

Queen Elizabeth II attends Royal Ascot 2021: photo

To the races! Queen Elizabeth II returned to Royal Ascot after having to skip it last year due to the...

New photos from John Cena’s ‘Peacemaker’ set reveal vigilante actor New photos from John Cena’s ‘Peacemaker’ set reveal vigilante actor
Entertainment55 mins ago

New photos from John Cena’s ‘Peacemaker’ set reveal vigilante actor

New photos from the set of the upcoming HBO Max series Pacifier starring John Cena reveals actor Freddie Stroma as...

Lauren Burnham, Arie Luyendyk Jr. bring their daughter home from the hospital Lauren Burnham, Arie Luyendyk Jr. bring their daughter home from the hospital
Entertainment1 hour ago

Lauren Burnham, Arie Luyendyk Jr. bring their daughter home from the hospital

Welcome home! Lauren Burnham other Arie Luyendyk Jr.The newborn daughter left the hospital on Saturday, June 19. “The best early...

Stacey Abrams on political office, the right to vote, June 19th – Tribeca – News Block Stacey Abrams on political office, the right to vote, June 19th – Tribeca – News Block
Entertainment1 hour ago

Stacey Abrams on political office, the right to vote, June 19th – Tribeca – News Block

Stacey Abrams hinted at a future political office (no wonder) defended a compromise on the voting rights bill “because we...

Who are they dating off set? Who are they dating off set?
Entertainment1 hour ago

Who are they dating off set?

Happy forever! Brianne howey, Scott porter and more Ginny and Georgia Actors explore romance on the Netflix show, but many...

KUWTK: Kylie Jenner remembers a guy who made her feel ‘impossible to kiss’ before putting on lip fillers! KUWTK: Kylie Jenner remembers a guy who made her feel ‘impossible to kiss’ before putting on lip fillers!
Entertainment2 hours ago

KUWTK: Kylie Jenner remembers a guy who made her feel ‘impossible to kiss’ before putting on lip fillers!

Despite the fact that many people look up to celebrities and generally consider them the standard of beauty and style,...

Advertisement

Tech

Best Outdoor Projection Screens 2021 Best Outdoor Projection Screens 2021
Tech1 hour ago

Best Outdoor Projection Screens 2021

Best outdoor projection screens Me more 2021 The best outdoor projectors are ideal for watching movies or the latest shows...

Best Cases for AirPods Pro 2021 Best Cases for AirPods Pro 2021
Tech2 hours ago

Best Cases for AirPods Pro 2021

Best Cases for AirPods Pro Me more 2021 You love your AirPods Pro and would like to protect the case...

Lawmakers Weren’t ‘Creative or Enthusiastic’ Enough to Fix Big Tech Antitrust Laws Lawmakers Weren’t ‘Creative or Enthusiastic’ Enough to Fix Big Tech Antitrust Laws
Tech2 hours ago

Lawmakers Weren’t ‘Creative or Enthusiastic’ Enough to Fix Big Tech Antitrust Laws

CEOs of big tech companies like Apple have been “allowed to do whatever they want,” according to Rep. David Cicilline...

Google Force Installs Massachusetts COVID-19 App on Resident Phones Google Force Installs Massachusetts COVID-19 App on Resident Phones
Tech2 hours ago

Google Force Installs Massachusetts COVID-19 App on Resident Phones

Google is forcibly installing a Massachusetts COVID-19 tracking app on residents’ Android devices without an easy way to uninstall it....

Best Prime Day AirPods Deals: Save on AirPods, AirPods Pro and AirPods Max Best Prime Day AirPods Deals: Save on AirPods, AirPods Pro and AirPods Max
Tech3 hours ago

Best Prime Day AirPods Deals: Save on AirPods, AirPods Pro and AirPods Max

This story is part of Amazon Prime Day 2021, CNET’s guide to everything you need to know and how to...

Prime Day Chromebook deals: the best we’ve found so far, starting at $ 169 Prime Day Chromebook deals: the best we’ve found so far, starting at $ 169
Tech3 hours ago

Prime Day Chromebook deals: the best we’ve found so far, starting at $ 169

This story is part of Amazon Prime Day 2021, CNET’s guide to everything you need to know and how to...

NBA Playoffs – Watch and Stream Bucks vs. Nets Game 7 on TNT NBA Playoffs – Watch and Stream Bucks vs. Nets Game 7 on TNT
Tech3 hours ago

NBA Playoffs – Watch and Stream Bucks vs. Nets Game 7 on TNT

The 2021 NBA playoffs are in full swing, with pivotal games between the best teams every day. They are broadcast...

Best Prime Day 2021 Ring Deals – Save $ 170 on a Refurbished Ring Video Doorbell Elite Best Prime Day 2021 Ring Deals – Save $ 170 on a Refurbished Ring Video Doorbell Elite
Tech4 hours ago

Best Prime Day 2021 Ring Deals – Save $ 170 on a Refurbished Ring Video Doorbell Elite

This story is part of Amazon Prime Day 2021, CNET’s guide to everything you need to know and how to...

South Korea’s Nuclear Research agency breached using VPN flaw South Korea’s Nuclear Research agency breached using VPN flaw
Tech4 hours ago

South Korea’s Nuclear Research agency breached using VPN flaw

South Korea’s ‘Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute’ revealed yesterday that its internal networks were hacked last month by North Korean...

Best Prime Day Tablet Deals So Far: $ 30 Off iPad Now, Plus Huge Fire HD 10 Price Cut Soon Best Prime Day Tablet Deals So Far: $ 30 Off iPad Now, Plus Huge Fire HD 10 Price Cut Soon
Tech4 hours ago

Best Prime Day Tablet Deals So Far: $ 30 Off iPad Now, Plus Huge Fire HD 10 Price Cut Soon

This story is part of Amazon Prime Day 2021, CNET’s guide to everything you need to know and how to...

Advertisement
Advertisement