Skip to content

I Attempted 9 Bind-Purchased Chocolate Chip Cookies & One Prevailed

The product suggestions on this submit are suggestions by means of the editor and/or professional(s) interviewed and don’t comprise associate hyperlinks. That means: Should you virtue those hyperlinks to shop for one thing, we can now not earn a fee.

Chocolate chip cookies could also be some of the liked and mawkish American cakes. It’s now not crisp to search out vast chocolate-packed cookies at bakeries, chain eating places, or within the snack aisle on the grocery shop.

A fresh-from-the-oven do-it-yourself cookie is absolute best, but if the yearning moves and also you don’t have dough available, your absolute best guess is to get a bundle of cookies on the shop. From tiny crunchy bites to vast doughy soft-baked cookies, there’s negative rarity of sorts to quell your cookie yearning.

With all of those choices, it may be crisp to grasp what, if the rest, differentiates one store-bought cookie from the after. To respond to the ones questions and construct your dessert buying groceries more uncomplicated, I examined 9 of probably the most pervasive store-bought cookies at grocery retail outlets.

I attempted each and every cookie instantly from the bundle and took word of its appears to be like, taste, and texture. Pour your self a majestic glass of chilly milk and get able to dunk. Right here’s how the 9 chocolate chip cookies ranked, in descending line:

Pepperidge Farm Nantucket Cookies

pepperidge farm nantucket cookiespepperidge farm nantucket cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to Cookie):
Energy: 140
Heavy: 7 g (Saturated Heavy: 3.5 g)
Sodium: 65 mg
Carbs: 19 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 11 g)
Protein: 2 g

As a Massachusetts local, I had top hopes for these Nantucket-branded cookieshowever they left one thing to be desired when it got here to texture and chocolate content material.

The glance: Those have been one of the crucial better chocolate chip cookies I examined. The picture at the entrance of the pouch displays a yellowish cookie brimming with excess chunks of unlit chocolate. Sadly, the cookies inside of have been missing within the chocolate branch. One cookie contained a unmarried, unhappy chocolate chew.

The style: Those cookies have been withered and crisp, bordering on stale. Alternative chocolate would have stepped forward the feel and made issues extra attention-grabbing, however I discovered them crisp and just a little lifeless total.

RELATED: 9 Chains That Lend the Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookies

Chips Ahoy! Fresh Chocolate Chip Cookies

chips ahoy cookieschips ahoy cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to 3 Cookies):
Energy: 160
Heavy: 8 g (Saturated Heavy: 3 g)
Sodium: 105 mg
Carbs: 22 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 10 g)
Protein: 2 g

The classic grocery store chocolate chip cookie used to be valuable and uniform however couldn’t moderately rise as much as one of the crucial extra attention-grabbing cookies on this take a look at.

The glance: Chips Ahoy! Cookies are nearly eerily matching. Each and every piece seems like a carbon booklet of the cookie after to it, which is quite unsettling with a deal with that’s most often charmingly distinctive. Those cookies are splattered with miniature chocolate chips on peak and feature only a few chocolate items combined into the middle.

The style: Those cookies are two-bite-sized and moderately withered. They fracture and disintegrate right into a sandy texture very simply, and the chocolate items are so modest you’ll be able to slightly style them.

Keebler Chips Deluxe Cushy Accumulation

keebler cookieskeebler cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (2 Cookies):
Energy: 150
Heavy: 7 g (Saturated Heavy: 3 g)
Sodium: 115 mg
Carbs: 21 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 12 g)
Protein: 1 g

As somebody who prefers tender cookies over withered ones, I used to be interested by these soft-baked cookies from Keebler. Those cookies are made with extra soybean and palm oil than the crunchier cookies I sampled—substances that backup guard their flexible texture and restrain them from tasting stale.

The glance: Those cookies seemed other from each alternative deal with I examined. They’re moderately clean, nearly yellow (they comprise caramel colour and yellow Negative. 6 meals dye), and feature only a few optical chocolate chips.

The style: I did benefit from the tender, chewy texture of those cookies, however I additionally discovered them tremendous candy and a negligible faux tasting, indubitably some distance from do-it-yourself. They’re low on chocolate, and the few chips you get are moderately candy.

Again to Nature Miniature Chocolate Bite Cookies

back to nature cookiesback to nature cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to Pouch):
Energy: 170
Heavy: 8 g (Saturated Heavy: 2 g)
Sodium: 85 mg
Carbs: 23 g (Fiber: 0 g, Sugar: 11 g)
Protein: 1 g

These petite cookies are packaged in snack luggage to pop right into a lunch field. They’re plant-based and made with wheat flour and semi-sweet chocolate chips. They’re advertised as 170-calorie luggage. This used to be the absolute best per-serving calorie content material of any product I examined.

The glance: Each and every plastic pouch incorporates about six tiny cookies plus some chocolate chunks that fell off in transit. Those cookies have a splendid appearing of chocolate chunks and a heat yellowish colour.

The style: It could be entire wheat flour, however those cookies tasted fitter than the alternative treats I examined. They’re made with safflower oil rather of butter or eggs as a result of they’re plant-based. The cookies don’t have as affluent prosperous a taste as one of the crucial others I examined.

Tate’s Bake Store Walnut Chocolate Chip Cookies

tate's cookiestate's cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to 2 Cookies):
Energy: 140
Heavy: 7 g (Saturated Heavy: 4.5 g)
Sodium: 160 mg
Carbs: 18 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 12 g)
Protein: 2 g

It’s unimaginable to retirement the iconic green Tate’s cookie packages on the grocery shop, no less than in Untouched York Town, the place I reside. The chocolate chip selection is a favourite amongst withered cookie fanatics.

The glance: Chocolate chips are the primary element indexed on Tate’s packaging, and those cookies do comprise extra chocolate than many of the others I examined. The chocolate items are tiny, so don’t be expecting fat, enjoyable chunks. The cookies are tremendous slim and flat with tapered edges. They’re better in diameter than many of the cookies I sampled.

The style: As a tender cookie gal, I didn’t love the crunchy texture of Tate’s, however the vintage taste (those cookies are made with actual butter, now not oil) made up for my textural desire. This model contained walnuts, however the nuts have been so finely chopped that it used to be simple to fail to remember them. Nonetheless, they added a pleasant nutty background word and difference crunch. I would really like a extra chocolaty chunk, however I will be able to’t whinge in regards to the not-too-sweet, buttery taste.

RELATED: Costco Customers Are Raving About Scrumptious, Soften-In-Your-Mouth Cookies

Made Excellent Chocolate Chip Cookies

made good cookiesmade good cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to 4 Cookies):
Energy: 160
Heavy: 9 g (Saturated Heavy: 4 g)
Sodium: 75 mg
Carbs: 19 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 9 g)
Protein: 1 g

These cookies have the bottom sugar content material according to serving and comprise “nutrients from vegetable extracts.” A better have a look at the element panel confirms that the cookies are made with spinach, broccoli, carrot, tomato, beet, and mushroom extracts (that’s a batch of extracts!). You’ll be able to’t inform from the glance or style, however should you’re determined for nutrients for your dessert, those chocolate chip cookies do business in 20 p.c of your advisable day-to-day consumption of nutrients D, A, E, C, and thiamin.

The glance: Those bite-sized cookies have a paler tan colour than others and a sandy, crumbly texture. They’re made with a excellent quantity of modest chocolate chips.

The style: I loved the flippantly candy taste of those cookies. They’re vegan and don’t have the vintage buttery taste, however I love that they’re now not cloying or overly affluent prosperous. Fortunately, there used to be negative hint of mushroom taste.

Newman’s Personal Chocolate Chip Cookies

newmans own cookiesnewmans own cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to 5 Cookies):
Energy: 150
Heavy: 7 g (Saturated Heavy: 4 g)
Sodium: 105 mg
Carbs: 20 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 10 g)
Protein: 2 g

These crunchy little cookies are full of chocolate chips and made with oats and standard substances like flour, sugar, and chocolate chips. Even though now not vegan, they’re made with palm fruit oil rather of butter.

The glance: Those cookies had a promising dough to chocolate chip ratio. They’re withered and crumbly and about the similar dimension, perhaps quite thicker, because the alternative bite-sized treats I examined.

The style: Those cookies are all in regards to the chocolate I like. The chocolate chips are assertive and ample, and the cookies aren’t overly candy. Sure, they’re crunchy however have a lovely texture and near-homemade taste strengthened by means of the nutty oats.

RELATED: The 2024 Lady Scout Cookie Lineup Was once Simply Open—However You Might Be Disillusioned

Matt’s Bakery Chocolate Chip Cookies

matts cookiesmatts cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to Cookie):
Energy: 140
Heavy: 7 g (Saturated Heavy: 3 g)
Sodium: 40 mg
Carbs: 19 g (Fiber: 1 g, Sugar: 10 g)
Protein: 1 g

This soft-baked option from Matt’s Bakery is made with habitual substances you’d most likely virtue in your chocolate chip cookies. The packaging lists flour, chocolate chips, oil, brown and white sugars, and eggs because the peak substances.

The glance: Those soft-baked cookies are pleasantly full of unlit chocolate chunks and feature an old style do-it-yourself glance. They’re delightfully lumpy and asymmetric and may simply cross for a latest dozen from a house oven.

The style: I like the chewy texture, sufficient inclusion of chocolate chunks, and completely candy taste. Those cookies have a mischievous caramel taste (most likely from the brown sugar) that provides richness.

Milk Bar Crunchies Brown Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies

milk bar cookiesmilk bar cookies
Lizzy Briskin, Devour This, No longer That!

Vitamin (According to 6 Cookies):
Energy: 150
Heavy: 6 g (Saturated Heavy: 3 g)
Sodium: 90 mg
Carbs: 21 g (Fiber: 0 g, Sugar: 12 g)
Protein: 1 g

This grocery product from cult-favorite bakery Milk Bar lives as much as what you’d be expecting from Milk Bar founder and candies queen Christina Tosi: over-the-top taste, sugar, and common indulgence.

The glance: Because the title suggests, those cookies are crunchy and withered. They’re mini bites that don’t have the factory-perfect glance of a few alternative packaged cookies I attempted. In lieu, they’ve the herbal ridges and mounds of a do-it-yourself cookie with enough of optical mix-ins.

The style: Like many Milk Bar pieces, those candies are smartly balanced with a slightly of salt. That savoriness brings out the richness of the browned butter and cuts any cloying notes from the sugar and chocolate chips. Those cookies are even crunchier than your conventional sun-baked bite-sized snacks because of the clever inclusion of puffed rice cereal, which reinforces the feel and enjoyable chunk.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *